2008년 10월 09일
표절논문 딱걸렸어
네이쳐 뉴스
요점은, 이제 남의 논문 슥삭슥삭 베껴다가 딴 데 내면 그거 딱 잡아주는 웹사이트까지 등장했다는 것이고
문제는 한국의 어떤 논문 하나가 이전에 발표된 남의 외국논문을 완전히 동일하게 훔쳐다가 국내학술지에 낸 것이 걸려서
이슈화되었다는 점. 심지어는 데이터 그림까지 몽땅 동일하게 베껴냈는데. 내참.
이 외에도 한국저자의 표절로 의심되는 것들이 발견되고 있는데,
가령 이런 논문 과 저런 논문 이 발견되었는데 (이런 논문 : 2006년, 저런 논문 : 1999년)
이런 논문의 초록
The crude herbal formulation, Gamgungtang (GGT), is an immunomodulatorshowing marked down-regulation of several experimental autoimmunediseases. In this study, its effect on different experimental models ofthyroid disease was investigated. Although very effective at preventingthyroid infiltrates in mice immunized with mouse deglycosylatedthyroglobulin and complete Freund's adjuvant and in spontaneous modelsof thyroiditis, it completely failed to modify experimental autoimmunethyroiditis (EAT) induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulinand lipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the GGT. One surprising fact to emerge was thatGGT-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with GGT. It is possiblethat the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with the trafficking ofprimed effector cells.
저런 논문의 초록
The drug Linomide is an immunomodulator showing marked down-regulationof several experimental autoimmune diseases. In this study, its effecton three different experimental models of thyroid disease and onspontaneous infiltration of salivary glands (sialoadenitis), wasinvestigated. Although very effective at preventing thyroid infiltratesin mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin and complete Freund'sadjuvant and in spontaneous models of thyroiditis and sialoadenitis, itcompletely failed to modify experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT)induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin andlipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the drug. One surprising fact to emerge was thatLinomide-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with Linomide. It ispossible that the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with thetrafficking of primed effector cells.
알기 쉽게 '저런 논문' 과 '이런 논문' 의 초록 중 다른 글자들만 색으로 칠해봤습니다.
The drug Linomide is an immunomodulator showing marked down-regulationof several experimental autoimmune diseases. In this study, its effecton three different experimental models of thyroid disease and onspontaneous infiltration of salivary glands (sialoadenitis), wasinvestigated. Although very effective at preventing thyroid infiltratesin mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin and complete Freund'sadjuvant and in spontaneous models of thyroiditis and sialoadenitis, itcompletely failed to modify experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT)induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin andlipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the drug. One surprising fact to emerge was thatLinomide-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with Linomide. It ispossible that the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with thetrafficking of primed effector cells.
뭔 넘의 물질인지 모르겠지만 남의 논문의 초록 물질 이름만 '검색 치환' 해서 논문 쓰시네요? ㅎㅎ 연구업적 내기 쉽군요.
다른 물질인지 전자안에 후자가 들어있는지 모르겠지만 어쨌든 두개를 처리해도 완전히 결론이 같은 (문장이 같은데 뭐) 그런
일 자체의 연구로써의 가치도 좀 의심스럽지만, 뭐 그거야 어쨌든, 남의 초록을 이렇게 빌려쓰는 것은 표절이예요. 아주 질나쁜.
요점은, 이제 남의 논문 슥삭슥삭 베껴다가 딴 데 내면 그거 딱 잡아주는 웹사이트까지 등장했다는 것이고
문제는 한국의 어떤 논문 하나가 이전에 발표된 남의 외국논문을 완전히 동일하게 훔쳐다가 국내학술지에 낸 것이 걸려서
이슈화되었다는 점. 심지어는 데이터 그림까지 몽땅 동일하게 베껴냈는데. 내참.
이 외에도 한국저자의 표절로 의심되는 것들이 발견되고 있는데,
가령 이런 논문 과 저런 논문 이 발견되었는데 (이런 논문 : 2006년, 저런 논문 : 1999년)
이런 논문의 초록
The crude herbal formulation, Gamgungtang (GGT), is an immunomodulatorshowing marked down-regulation of several experimental autoimmunediseases. In this study, its effect on different experimental models ofthyroid disease was investigated. Although very effective at preventingthyroid infiltrates in mice immunized with mouse deglycosylatedthyroglobulin and complete Freund's adjuvant and in spontaneous modelsof thyroiditis, it completely failed to modify experimental autoimmunethyroiditis (EAT) induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulinand lipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the GGT. One surprising fact to emerge was thatGGT-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with GGT. It is possiblethat the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with the trafficking ofprimed effector cells.
저런 논문의 초록
The drug Linomide is an immunomodulator showing marked down-regulationof several experimental autoimmune diseases. In this study, its effecton three different experimental models of thyroid disease and onspontaneous infiltration of salivary glands (sialoadenitis), wasinvestigated. Although very effective at preventing thyroid infiltratesin mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin and complete Freund'sadjuvant and in spontaneous models of thyroiditis and sialoadenitis, itcompletely failed to modify experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT)induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin andlipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the drug. One surprising fact to emerge was thatLinomide-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with Linomide. It ispossible that the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with thetrafficking of primed effector cells.
알기 쉽게 '저런 논문' 과 '이런 논문' 의 초록 중 다른 글자들만 색으로 칠해봤습니다.
The drug Linomide is an immunomodulator showing marked down-regulationof several experimental autoimmune diseases. In this study, its effecton three different experimental models of thyroid disease and onspontaneous infiltration of salivary glands (sialoadenitis), wasinvestigated. Although very effective at preventing thyroid infiltratesin mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin and complete Freund'sadjuvant and in spontaneous models of thyroiditis and sialoadenitis, itcompletely failed to modify experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT)induced in mice immunized with mouse thyroglobulin andlipopolysaccharide. There was no significant shift in the observedisotypes of anti-mouse thyroglobulin antibodies and only anti-mousethyroglobulin antibodies in the spontaneous model were completelydown-modulated by the drug. One surprising fact to emerge was thatLinomide-treated donor mice, although protected from thyroid lesionsthemselves, were still able to transfer EAT showing that they must havebeen effectively primed while being treated with Linomide. It ispossible that the drug down modulated EAT by interfering with thetrafficking of primed effector cells.
뭔 넘의 물질인지 모르겠지만 남의 논문의 초록 물질 이름만 '검색 치환' 해서 논문 쓰시네요? ㅎㅎ 연구업적 내기 쉽군요.
다른 물질인지 전자안에 후자가 들어있는지 모르겠지만 어쨌든 두개를 처리해도 완전히 결론이 같은 (문장이 같은데 뭐) 그런
일 자체의 연구로써의 가치도 좀 의심스럽지만, 뭐 그거야 어쨌든, 남의 초록을 이렇게 빌려쓰는 것은 표절이예요. 아주 질나쁜.
# by | 2008/10/09 14:34 | Science | 트랙백 | 덧글(1)
